------------------------------------------------------------------- DAWN WIRE SERVICE ------------------------------------------------------------------- Week Ending : 06 February 1997 Issue : 03/06 -------------------------------------------------------------------

Contents | National News | Business & Economy | Editorials & Features | Sports

The DAWN Wire Service (DWS) is a free weekly news-service from Pakistan's largest English language newspaper, the daily DAWN. DWS offers news, analysis and features of particular interest to the Pakistani Community on the Internet. Extracts from DWS can be used provided that this entire header is included at the beginning of each extract. We encourage comments & suggestions. We can be reached at: e-mail dws@dawn.khi.erum.com.pk dws%dawn%khi@sdnpk.undp.org fax +92(21) 568-3188 & 568-3801 mail Pakistan Herald Publications (Pvt.) Limited DAWN Group of Newspapers Haroon House, Karachi 74400, Pakistan TO START RECEIVING DWS FREE EVERY WEEK, JUST SEND US YOUR E-MAIL ADDRESS! (c) Pakistan Herald Publications (Pvt.) Ltd., Pakistan - 1996 ******************************************************************* ******* Eid Greetings * Eid Greetings * Eid Greetings ******* ******************************************************************* Eid Mubarak!! We would like to wish all our readers a happy and prosperous Eid. ******************************************************************** *****DAWN - the Internet Edition ** DAWN - the Internet Edition***** ******************************************************************** Read DAWN - the Internet Edition on the WWW ! http://xiber.com/dawn Pakistan's largest English language newspaper, DAWN, is now Pakistan's first newspaper on the WWW. DAWN - the Internet Edition will be published daily (except on Fridays and public holidays in Pakistan) and would be available on the Web by noon GMT. Check us out ! DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS

CONTENTS

===================================================================

NATIONAL NEWS

Benazir wants new govt to complete term Mystery shrouds delay in results Infomercials make the poll different from past ones US confirms two charges against PDF govt PML-N routs PDF bloc in Punjab Pajero ride tempts voter to cast ballot Imran out for a duck Low turnout marks elections EU observers point out deficiencies in poll process PPP rejects election results PML emerges over-all winner in elections ---------------------------------

BUSINESS & ECONOMY

Nawaz has agreed to continue economic changes Businessmen optimistic about revival of economy FDI worth $16.73bn expected in 9th Plan The economics of elections Burki terms situation in Pakistan disappointing Volume soars to record 88m shares on Nawazs victory ---------------------------------------

EDITORIALS & FEATURES

Dissolution 1996 Ardeshir Cowasjee Benazirs refreshing stance Editorial Column *From Jinnah to Benazir and after Dr I.H. Malik The moment of truth Mazdak -----------

SPORTS

A fitting case for world Test championship Rashid Latif not available for Dhaka trip Five-nation event to be held in Karachi Akram decides to skip international events Will results affect PCB set-up? PSFs obligation and future of squash

DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 
=================================================================== 

NATIONAL NEWS

970205 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Benazir wants new govt to complete term ------------------------------------------------------------------- Bureau Report ISLAMABAD, Feb 4: Former prime minister Benazir Bhutto has said though election results have been engineered, she will give a chance to Nawaz Sharif to complete his tenure. If I launch a movement (against the government for rigging the elections) it will only result in the dismissal of another assembly. What will people get? Bhutto told an over-crowded news conference in the Federal Capital on Tuesday after her arrival from Larkana. Where do we go from here? Neither the people of Pakistan, the nation, the PPP or I can afford another election physically or politically, the former prime minister whose party has won only 17 seats in the 217-member National Assembly said. The PPP has been routed completely from three out of four provinces in the general elections. As far as I am concerned, I derive a quiet satisfaction from the failure of President Leghari to form a Kings Party, to have a hung parliament and to impose a presidential system, the former prime minister said. For better or worse, Nawaz Sharif and the PML have been given charge of this country. They have been in effect been given a blank cheque to re- write the Constitution, Ms Bhutto said. I wish Mian Nawaz Sharif good luck. The former prime minister said she wanted to break the vicious circle where the assembly is not given a chance to complete its tenure. She said though the election results were engineered, she would like to see democracy strengthen its roots in the country. I want to see parliamentary democracy to flourish, she added. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970204 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Mystery shrouds delay in results ------------------------------------------------------------------- Bureau Report ISLAMABAD, Feb 3: The Election Commission announced the first result at 12:45 AM, a record of sorts because in the previous elections the first results had begun coming in within six hours of polling. Every time the Election Commission was approached by reporters for results the stock answer was: Wait for some more time. The officials of the Commission also said that since the results of the provincial assemblies were also being compiled, so the delay. It was also for the first time that the reporters were debarred from entering into the Control Room of the Election Commission and were asked to sit on the second floor of the ministry of state and frontier region raising questions about the transparency of the election process. President Farooq Leghari visited the Election Commission at about nine Oclock and inspected various arrangements made for announcing the results and expressed his satisfaction over it. The reporters were not even allowed to move around with the President in the Commission which too was some thing totally unexpected and unprecedented. The staff on duty in the Commission was also hostile to media and did not permit any one to even come near the control room. On being questioned, they were told to remain away from the control room and wait for the results of the election on the television. Interestingly the delay in announcing the consolidated results occurred despite the fact that the Election Commission had made arrangements to announce the results of the elections of each polling station on the spot. Everyone expected that the results would start coming after 9.30 because of the low turn out. In all previous elections, at least unofficial results started coming by 10 pm. No plausible explanation was offered either by the Election Commission or any responsible official of the caretaker government as to why newsmen were not allowed to have access to the control room which at time looked more of an office of any security agency than the office which was responsible to facilitate the media. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970203 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Infomercials make the poll different from past ones ------------------------------------------------------------------- Nizamuddin Siddiqui KARACHI, Feb 2: Mondays parliamentary elections do not seem very different from the previous elections of the country. Like so many past elections, this one, too, is being held under a caretaker government, the elected government having been dismissed by the president. There is, therefore, a lot of chaos and bitterness in the air. There is, however, one thing which sets Mondays elections apart from the previous ones, thanks largely to television advertisements by the contending parties to disseminate their messages. Not all the political parties have used the TV ads to spread their messages. But the four which have done so, have shown a lot of gusto and imagination in propagating their image. The enthusiasm of the four parties for the television ads can be gauged from their performance on Saturday night alone. They paid Rs 3.72 million to buy 42 minutes and 15 seconds, or 14.08 per cent, of prime time (from 7:20pm to 12:20am). With the adverts of them  Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), Pakistan Muslim League (Nawaz), Tehrik-i-Insaf, and Tehrik-i-Jafria  dominating the total time slated for advertisements, very few commercial ads were aired. During the period mentioned, 25 political messages were aired by the PTV in all. In other words, on an average, a political ad was aired after every 12 minutes. Almost all the adverts were based on personalities rather than on issues with all the four parties showing their party leaders extensively. Only one ad from the PPP and one from the PML(N) spoke of economic issues. One PPP message showed Nusrat Bhutto endorsing the policies of her daughter, Benazir Bhutto. The short TIP message showed Imran Khan appealing to the voters to go to the polling stations on their own, since, he claimed, his party lacked resources to provide conveyance to the voters. The TIPs 25-minute infomercial that was aired on Saturday night was actually the rerun of the PTV programme called Election Hour. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970201 ------------------------------------------------------------------- US sends signal to Pakistan politicians ------------------------------------------------------------------- Shaheen Sehbai WASHINGTON, Jan 31: The US has sent a clear message to politicians in Pakistan that if they did not put their act together, Washington would be willing to work comfortably with the army, even under a barely concealed military regime, analysts said on Friday. Reviewing the latest US human rights report on Pakistan, they said it recognised that the  troika governs Pakistan, that it stated categorically that the judiciary was not independent, it blasted politicians for their acts of commission and omission and, between the lines, expressed satisfaction that the Benazir government had been dismissed. It is just good luck that the judgement in the Benazir Bhutto case came before this report. Had it been delayed and this report had appeared before the judgement, Benazir and the Supreme Court would have been put in a difficult situation as many conclusions drawn in the report had a direct bearing on the Benazir case, a diplomat said. The report conveys strong political opinions of the US administration about Pakistans domestic affairs and in view of the importance Robin Raphel gave to the army chief while ignoring the prime minister during her recent visit, it should become clear that the state department is no longer hooked to a strong commitment for democratic rule in Pakistan, analysts say. The troika was mentioned in the human rights report for 1995 as well and although it is a reality in Pakistan, the analysts are still questioning whether an official government document could recognise it as such without kicking off a diplomatic row. No such row started last year and none is expected this year. The US policy is evident, the analysts say, from the reaction of the state department to the dismissal of the Benazir government and to the formation of the CDNS, when no doubt was left that Washington would not intervene on the side of the politicians unless a blatant and direct military rule was imposed. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970204 ------------------------------------------------------------------- PML-N routs PDF bloc in Punjab ------------------------------------------------------------------- Mahmood Zaman LAHORE, Feb 3: The Pakistan Muslim Leagues success in the Punjab Assembly polls was as comprehensive as its win on the provinces National Assembly seats. It was reported to have bagged 108 PA seats in the 248-member house, according to unofficial results received till last reports came in. The Pakistan Peoples Party not only lost in all provincial constituencies except two, the margin of its defeat was startlingly large. It was a rout in a province which had helped to bring two Bhuttos to power twice in 26 years. It now seems as if the largest province has withdrawn its support to the PPP. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970204 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Pajero ride tempts voter to cast ballot ------------------------------------------------------------------- Shaukat Ali LAHORE, Feb 3: The chance to sit in a Pajero was one compelling factor which made Baba Rahima  a voter in village Manga (polling station number 42) in NA 99  to cast his vote. Aged around 60, he felt overjoyed sitting in a glistening blue Pajero owned by a contestant. I dont care who wins or loses. I have enjoyed (the ride), a gleeful Baba Rahima said. Talking to this correspondent he said it had been a life-long dream for him to sit in a Pajero. When asked whom he had voted for, the baba said: Obviously for my benefactor. The Pajero was bountifully decorated with stickers. A number of other jeeps were also seen in the area bringing voters. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970204 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Imran out for a duck ------------------------------------------------------------------- Ihtashamul Haque ISLAMABAD, Feb 3: The cricket star turned politician Imran Khan who contested the election for eight national assembly seats, failed to win a single seat, ending any thought that he would emerge as a third political force in the country. Mr Khan who now heads the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf political party, besides running a cancer hospital, was believed to be winning at least his personal seat along with bagging couple of more seats for his partymen. However, he could not be returned to the national assembly as was generally being projected by both political and non-political quarters. Analysts said that he too was the victim of the new wave that ran across the country in favour of Pakistan Muslim League(N) and despite having lot of support from the youth, he did not even secure a single seat for himself. He is on record as having said in a TV interview that he did not care even if he would not secure a single seat, and that he has a long way to go in politics to make his presence felt both in the public and the establishment. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970204 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Low turnout marks elections ------------------------------------------------------------------- Dawn Report ISLAMABAD, Feb 3: Early trends indicated that the election 1997 which was characterised by an unusually low turnout was going in favour of the Pakistan Muslim League of Nawaz Sharif. President Farooq Leghari while talking to reporters at the PTV election studio late in the evening disclosed that in urban Punjab the turn out was 26 per cent while in rural areas it was 27 per cent. The nine-hour long, largely peaceful polling for the national and provincial assemblies ended today at the appointed time with the voter turnout remaining significantly low throughout the country. In most of the constituencies polling started about one to two hour late due to administrative problems and in the Punjab and Federal capital foggy weather also intervened. The pace of voting also remained very slow and the general pattern of low turnout was clearly visible every where. While the uncertainty about polls which had remained high throughout the three months and the fact that the election rules had made it almost impossible for the candidates to spend lavishly on their campaigns had had a dampening impact on the election activity. The main reason for the low turnout appeared to be the doubts harboured by voters about the fate of winning candidates who, according to the new laws, could be disqualified either because they had spent more than the limit imposed on election expenses or because they had made wrong declaration of their assets. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970206 ------------------------------------------------------------------- EU observers point out deficiencies in poll process ------------------------------------------------------------------- Bureau Report ISLAMABAD, Feb 5: The European Union election observers group has monitored serious deficiencies in the electoral process, and advised Pakistan to hold an early census to avoid distortions in the system. In general the poll was conducted in accordance with the rules and in an equitable manner and that the results reflected the wishes of those who voted. However, serious deficiencies, in the electoral register and the identification of voters, excluded a significant proportion of those who had the right to vote, concluded the final report of the group here on Wednesday. It also said that the failure to hold a census since 1981, despite constitutional requirements, and rapid demographic change, had led to distortions and imbalances in the number and distribution of constituencies. There is no doubt that this detracts in a fundamental way from the representative character of the parliamentary system in Pakistan. It is important that a census be held and constituency boundaries be reviewed before the next elections, the report said. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970206 ------------------------------------------------------------------- PPP rejects election results ------------------------------------------------------------------- Bureau Report ISLAMABAD, Feb 5: The Central Executive Committee (CEC) of the Pakistan Peoples Party said on Wednesday that the February 3 general elections were massively rigged and refused to accept its results. However for promoting and protecting the parliamentary form of government and maintaining political and economic stability, the CEC decided that it would not launch any movement for the time being. The meeting, chaired by former prime minister Benazir Bhutto, considered at length the outcome of the general elections and accused the Secretary Election Commission of having a hostile attitude towards the party as he was suspended by the PPP government. The decision whether to sit in the assembly or not will be taken by the parliamentary party of the PPP in its meeting to be held a day before the assembly session, the CEC decided. The CEC was of the view that the people of Pakistan have been robbed of an opportunity to elect their representatives through a free, fair and impartial election. The process of manipulation was started with the installation of a hostile, biased, partial and highly controversial caretaker set up at the federal and provincial levels, the meeting observed. It said the caretakers immediately set up the state apparatus against the PPP by arresting its leaders and workers on false, frivolous charges and conducting a media trial of the party and its leadership on concocted charges, promulgation of tinted election laws aimed deliberately to give advantage to the adversaries of the PPP, manipulation of the local administration by way of transfers, postings and selective issuance of the national identity cards to the opponents of the PPP. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970205 ------------------------------------------------------------------- PML emerges over-all winner in elections ------------------------------------------------------------------- M. Ziauddin ISLAMABAD, Feb 4: Pakistan Muslim League led by Nawaz Sharif has swept the national and Punjab assemblies seats while in the NWFP it has shared the spoils with its former ally ANP and in Sindh and Balochistan it has made significant gains. The Balochistan National Party (BNP) has romped home in Balochistan with the largest number of seats. The unofficial results give the PML an absolute majority in the national and the Punjab assemblies while its nearest rival, the PPP, has been routed in all the provinces except in Sindh. The so-called third force, Tehrik-i-Insaf of Imran Khan, has failed to win even a single provincial or National Assembly seat. It is clear now that the PML will form governments at the Centre and the Punjab without entering into an alliance with other parties. Interestingly, in both the national and Punjab assemblies, the opposition would be almost non-existent while in NWFP too the opposition would be too insignificant if the PML and ANP join hands. It is not very clear which parties or party would sit in the opposition in Balochistan.

=================================================================== 

BUSINESS & ECONOMY

970206 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Nawaz has agreed to continue economic changes ------------------------------------------------------------------- Shaheen Sehbai WASHINGTON, Feb 5: The first test of the new PML Governments commitment to economic reforms would be whether they adopt the reforms and laws passed by the caretaker government, Adviser to PM on Finance, Mr. Shahid Javed Burki said on Wednesday. Talking to Dawn in Washington he said in initial meetings with him before the elections, the PML leadership had agreed to continue with the reforms but there would be political pressures on the new government to abandon some of the targets set by the IMF. Burki claimed that in three months the caretakers had done a great lot for which I am very proud of myself and the dream team that I had. A paper prepared on its achievements, the caretakers government claimed successes in three key areas - stabilisation of the economy, structural transformation and poverty alleviation. I stopped the nose dive and brought the economy to a plain, stable level, Mr. Burki claimed. Under the title of stabilisation of the economy, the government paper claims improvements were made in fiscal, monetary and external finances. The government expenditure was cut by Rs 36.1 billion or 7.2 per cent of the total GDP of Rs 500 billion, an improvement in resource mobilisation of Rs. 55.3 billion was achieved in Nov-Dec 96 as against last year and tight monetary policy reduced bank borrowing from Rs 65.7 billion on Oct 31 to Rs 58.8 billion on Dec 31, it said. In the external finances sector it claimed foreign exchange reserves were built up from $ 614 million in end of October to $ 836 million in December. Likewise trade gap declined to $ 160 million in December compared to $ 300 million in November. In structural reforms introduced by the caretaker government, Mr. Burki claimed 30 measures had been adopted in 13 different areas including reforms in the banking sector, monetary and fiscal policy, capital market, NFC, privatisation, re-defining governments role, trade and tariffs, improving statistical base and strengthening of planning process. Deregulation of the petroleum sector, packages for textile industry and drainage programme for agriculture besides establishment of a poverty alleviation fund, food vouchers and a safety net for the poor, encouraging private sector education and stipends for the poor were also part of the measures taken by the caretakers. Mr. Burki would be returning to Islamabad for a day or two to brief the new government leaders on Sunday but for all practical purposes he has finished his job assigned to him for three months. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970205 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Businessmen optimistic about revival of economy ------------------------------------------------------------------- Staff Reporter KARACHI, Feb 4: Businessmen are looking at the Monday election results which returned Mr Nawaz Sharifs Pakistan Muslim League with a thumping majority in National Assembly with optimism and in their statements on Tuesday have expressed the hope of revival of economic activities in the country. The PML(N) headed by Nawaz Sharif is being considered a businessmen friendly political party and industrialists and businessmen expect creation of an environment which would facilitate trade and industry in moving ahead. A new era has dawned and the country should witness economic progress and prosperity in the days ahead, hopes the President of Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry, Senator Ilays Ahmed Bilour. In a statement, he said that the success secured by Mr. Sharif is indicative of the fact that the people have confidence in him and consider him as the only person who could pull the country out of the present degeneration. He hoped that Mr Sharif would take the business community, particularly the FPCCI, along in formulating the economic policies of his government. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970202 ------------------------------------------------------------------- FDI worth $16.73bn expected in 9th Plan ------------------------------------------------------------------- Parvaiz Ishfaq Rana KARACHI, Feb 1: Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in Pakistan is expected to soar to $16.738 billion during the 9th Five-Year Plan to be launched next year owing to some major structural changes in the rules governing foreign capital. According to projections made by the Board of Investment (BoI) after taking into account the last five year plans capital inflow and the financial reforms undertaken by the former two governments of Nawaz Sharif and Benazir Bhutto, the FDI is expected to soar to $16.738 billion as against $1.654 billion inflow of FDI during 7th Five-Year Plan and $3.899 billion during the first four years of 8th Five-Year Plan, up to Dec 1996. FDIs are largely dependent on the perception of investors and the investment friendly incentives as well as environment, the board official said and added that they were subject to change because of economic and allied economic factors. Foreign investors also take into account the investment opportunities in the region surrounding Pakistan, they said adding there could be a possible shortfall in the projected figures from the actual inflows of FDI in subsequent years. Out of the total inflow of FDI during first four years of 8th Five-Year Plan (up to Dec 1996), an investment of $1.181 billion from USA topped the list followed by $928 million from UK and $167.3 million from Japan. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970201 ------------------------------------------------------------------- The economics of elections ------------------------------------------------------------------- Dr. Farrukh Saleem ELECTIONS or no elections, PML(N) is the only political entity that is already laughing all the way to the bank. One hundred and seventy- seven National Assembly (NA) candidates and around 30 dozen contestants on the four Provincial Assembly seats have had to cough up a good Rs 10 crore so that they could get their hands on what is being perceived as winning tickets. The top PPP hierarchy had also fetched black-market prices for their tickets both in 1988 and in 1993. This year PPP has given 160 NA tickets. Out of the one-hundred-and-sixty tickets, the PPP has surely managed small amounts from the feudal-dominated belt of Southern Punjab and from some rural constituencies in the interior of Sindh, but by and large Benazir, is finding it difficult to get much in return for party tickets. The PML, PPP, and some independent candidates have, in the meanwhile, been converting some of their dollars stashed away during previous regimes in order to finance their domestic election campaigns. The en masse conversion of dollars by potential legislators has improved the rupee-dollar parity from a low of Rs 43.50 to the current level of around Rs 41.90. The rupees strength, to be sure, is transient. This year there are 1,853 candidates on 217 NA seats and 4,424 contestants on 483 PA seats. While the CECs limit on election expenses stands at Rs 10 lakh for NA candidates and Rs 6 lakh of PA constituencies, most party- backed, especially PML and PPP candidates; would be spending anywhere from 250 per cent to 500 per cent higher than the CEC limit. There is bound to be widespread violations of CEC limits, but certainly not as severe as has been the case in previous elections. Tonga wallas in rural constituencies, bus owners, paid voters and muscle- men are all going to be employed and paid well by NA and PA candidates, but thanks to the new election laws noisy street rallies, rowdy party meetings, banners, party flags and placards of all sorts have been restricted giving a more docile look to the overall election campaign. Additionally, this election year may actually be the first time that all the three major party leaders- Nawaz, Benazir, and Imran have leased out helicopters in order to stay comfortable and also to visit more constituencies than has been possible in the past. The election may also set a new record as far as the number of women candidates contesting on general seats is concerned. There are some 38 constituencies on which female candidates are taking part. One of the most interesting is NA-164 where Begum Nusrat Bhutto, Ashraf Khatoon, Rasheeda Khohro, Sabiha Sultana and Ghinwa Bhutto are all candidates. All said and done, the 6,277 want to be legislators would have spent more than Rs 3 billion or an equivalent of some $75 million from the beginning of the election campaign up until February 3. Moving over to the Election Commission, it is still in the process of seeing up some 43,000 polling stations as opposed to 34,000 that were set up in 1993. The Commission has already engaged at least 6 lakh people to manage affairs at these polling stations. A total of 53,244 persons all of grade 17, 18, and 19 mostly from the Education Department are also being trained as Presiding Officers, Assistant Presiding Officers and ballot papers are still being printed. Estimated costs: Rs 10 crore. The Election Commission has also requested the assistance of 250,000 armed forces (108,000 were used 1993) personnel  150,000 at polling stations and an additional 100,000 to maintain law and order. Although this year the armed forces have decided not to change the routine internal security allowance this assistance (sought under Article 220) nevertheless involves an implicit expense of more than Rs 1 crore. This help from the armed forces is, of course, in addition to the CECs own workers whose numbers are expected to reach 600,000 at the cost of some Rs 20 crore. Between November 5 and February 3 the nation may eventually be poorer by Rs 100 crore on the election account alone. Considering that no more than 25 million voters would go out and actually cast their vote. That translates into an extremely high per-voter cost of Rs 200 per election (education budget Rs 12 per Pakistani per year, health budget Rs 24 per Pakistani per year) A comparison of election expenses to what that the government spends on education or on the health sector makes any election exercise even more depressing. The Budget 96-97 allocated a more Rs 160 crore for education and a party Rs 320 crore for the health sector. Just where do our national priorities really lie? Election or education? Election or health? Did the President even given any consideration to such issues before dissolving the assemblies? The possibility of restoration of the Assembly which is no more there has indeed been a cause for most candidates keeping their election expenses on a tight leash. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970131 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Burki terms situation in Pakistan disappointing ------------------------------------------------------------------- Bureau Report ISLAMABAD, Jan 30: The prime ministers adviser on finance, Shahid Javed Burki, left here for Washington on Thursday to represent Pakistan at a micro-enterprise summit there. I am going to Washington to represent Prime Minister Malik Meraj Khalid at a summit, convened to offer support to small industries in the developing countries, Mr Burki said before leaving Islamabad. He told reporters that he would stay in the United States for sometime after attending the summit and come back on February 10. Then I would finally go back to Washington on Feb 13, he said adding that he had no plans to serve any other future government in Pakistan. Answering a question , Mr Burki said he would also be meeting high officials of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund during his stay in the US. There is no specific agenda to be discussed with the World Bank and the IMF but I would hold talks with them on various issues including further support for the economic stabilisation programme in Pakistan, the adviser stated. He said both the institutions had been extremely helpful to Pakistan, specially in getting the country out of the crisis created by the Benazir government. Replying to a question, Mr Burki said the IMF had just released the third tranche of 76 million dollars. He hoped that the future government would continue to implement the reforms introduced by the caretakers , to avoid problems. Asked to comment on his stay in Pakistan, he said it was very disappointing. My biggest disappointment is that every institution in Pakistan has been destroyed and things look more horrifying when I find that people do not realise their responsibilities, Mr Burki said. He said there were many good people in every section of the society. It is true that a handful bad eggs have done the real damage but nobody is there to check them to stop further damage, he said. For me it was a painful shock to find corruption everyone, he said praying that the future government should realise the gravity of the problem and avoid indulging in corrupt practices and serve its people honestly. He said Pakistan was potentially a rich country and the only need was that its resources were utilised honestly and efficiently. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970205 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Volume soars to record 88m shares on Nawazs victory ------------------------------------------------------------------- Staff Reporter KARACHI, Feb 4: The Karachi Stock Exchange on Tuesday gave an enthusiastic welcome to the overwhelming victory of Nawaz Sharif in the national elections as the post-election session saw the 100-share index gaining another 52 points. Volume soared to a record figure of 88 million shares. There were no pleasant surprises in the rings as the market has already voted him to power in the pre-election sessions as was reflected by the buying euphoria. The victory is incredible even beyond the markets initial perceptions, some dealers said. It is a tidal wave which took the entire Punjab in its fold and wiped out everything which came in its way putting the former prime minister again in the saddle, another said. Dealers said the victory is overwhelming and there are reasons to believe that the current buying euphoria could be sustained in the coming sessions too. What is more important is that foreign investors are back in the rings in a big way and made massive buying on some of the leading MNCs at the lower levels. The market needs political stability to thrive and the current elections ensure it is there, said a leading foreign fund manager. Trading volume soared to 88 million shares, the fourth best single-session figure. The previous record being at 112.736 million shares established on March 28 in 1996 after the news of privatisation of Pakistan Telecommunication. PTC alone accounted for 55 million shares on that day. Stocks rise and fall with the Nawaz Sharif government, the post-election session proved an old adage in more than one ways, dealers said. The index gained over 100 points during the pre and post-elections sessions and consolidated its position well above the 1,600 points resistance level at 1,648.00 points as compared to 1,597.26 on Sunday. Most floor brokers believe that irrespective of the weak economy the sailing in the rings now on word might be smooth and there are reasons to believe that foreign investors might remain active buyers. Plus signs were again strewn all over the list as investors rushed in to cover positions at the lower levels. The interesting feature was that most of the textile shares virtually raced towards their pre-reaction levels under the lead of Nishat Mills and Asim Textiles, rising by Rs 3. Bank shares were also actively traded at the lower levels and rose in unison, major gainers among them being Askari Bank, Bank Al-Habib, Crescent Bank, Bankers Equity, PICIC and KASB & Co. Adamjee Insurance followed them rising by Rs 6 and so did Dadabhoy Insurance and EFU Life Insurance. Others also rose. Dewan Salman and Dhan Fibre were actively traded with the former showing a big increase of Rs 4.30 and so did Gatron Industries, rising by Rs 4. Energy shares also rose in unison under the lead of National Refinery and PSO, and so were most of the leading MNCs which showed good gains. However, biggest gains were noted in Siemens Pakistan, BOC Pakistan, Dawood Hercules, Gillette Pakistan and Pakistan Gum Chemicals, rising by Rs 3 to 8. Barring Fateh Textiles, which fell by Rs 5, other losses were modest and confined to 4th and 8th ICP mutual funds and Atlas Battery. The most active was again led by Hub-Power, which was massively traded, up 95 paisa on 20.810 million shares, followed by PTC vouchers, sharply higher by Rs 1.45 on 18.883m, Dewan Salman, sharply higher by Rs 4.30 on 12.209m, ICI Pakistan, up one rupee on 9.546m, and Dhan Fibre, higher 50 paisa on 5.485m shares. Other actively traded shares were led by FFC-Jordan Fertiliser, firm 95 paisa on 0.600m, Nishat Mills, up Rs 2 on 0.306m, LTV Modaraba, steady 75 paisa on 0.310m, and PICIC, higher one rupee on 0.236m shares. There were 278 actives out of which 231 shares rose, 15 fell with 32 holding on to the last levels. ------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBSCRIBE TO HERALD TODAY ! ------------------------------------------------------------------- Every month the Herald captures the issues, the pace and the action, shaping events across Pakistan's lively, fast-moving current affairs spectrum. Subscribe to Herald and get the whole story. Annual Subscription Rates : Latin America & Caribbean US$ 93 Rs. 2,700 North America & Australasia US$ 93 Rs. 2,700 Africa, East Asia Europe & UK US$ 63 Rs. 1,824 Middle East, Indian Sub-Continent & CAS US$ 63 Rs. 1,824 Please send the following information : Payments (payable to Herald) can be by crossed cheque (for Pakistani Rupees), or by demand draft drawn on a bank in New York, NY (for US Dollars). Name, Postal Address, Telephone, Fax, e-mail address, old subscription number (where applicable). Send payments and subscriber information to : G.M Circulation, The Herald P.O.Box 3740, Karachi, Pakistan We also accept payments through American Express, Visa or Master Card. Allow 45 days for first issue.
Back to the top.
=================================================================== 

EDITORIALS & FEATURES

970205 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Dissolution 1996 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Ardeshir Cowasjee FINALLY, pushed out of his bed early in the morning of Tuesday November 5, 1996, President Sardar Farooq Ahmed Khan, Tumandar of the Legharis, under the powers vested in him in terms of Article 58 (2)(B) of the Constitution, dissolved Benazir Bhuttos National Assembly, proclaiming: Whereas during the last three years thousands of persons in Karachi and other parts of Pakistan have been deprived of their right to life in violation of Article 9 of the Constitution. And Whereas on September 20, 1996 Mir Murtaza Bhutto, the brother of the Prime Minister, was killed in Karachi along with seven of his companions including the brother-in-law of a former Prime Minister, ostensibly in an encounter with the Karachi Police. The Prime Minister and her Government claimed that Mir Murtaza Bhutto has been murdered as part of a conspiracy. And whereas on March 20, 1996 the Supreme Court of Pakistan delivered its judgement in the case popularly known as the Appointment of Judges Case. The Prime Minister ridiculed the judgement in a speech before the National Assembly which was shown more than once on nation-wide television. The implementation of the judgement was resisted and deliberately delayed in violation of the Constitutional mandate that all executive and judicial authorities throughout Pakistan shall act in aid of the Supreme Court. And Whereas the sustained assault on the judicial organ of State has continued under the garb of a Bill moved in Parliament for the prevention of corrupt practices. And whereas the judiciary has still not been fully separated from the executive in violation of the provisions of Article 175(3) of the Constitution and the deadline for such separation fixed by the Supreme Court of Pakistan. And whereas the Prime Minister and her government have deliberately violated, on a massive scale, the fundamental right of privacy guaranteed by Article 14 of the Constitution. This has been done through illegal phone-tapping and eavesdropping techniques. The phones which have been tapped and the conversations that have been monitored in this unconstitutional manner includes phones and conversations of judges of the superior courts, leaders of political parties and high-ranking military and civil officers. And whereas corruption, nepotism and violation of rules in the administration of the affairs of the Government and its various bodies, authorities and corporations has become so extensive and widespread that the orderly functioning of Government in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution and the law has become impossible and in some cases national security has been endangered. Public faith in the integrity and honesty of the Government has disappeared. Members of the Government and the ruling parties are either directly or indirectly involved in such corruption, nepotism and rule violations. Innumerable appointments have been made at the instance of members of the National Assembly in violation of the law declared by the Supreme Court that allocation of quotas to MNAs and MPAs for recruitment to various posts was offensive to the Constitution and the law and that all appointments were to be made on merit, honestly and objectively and in the public interest. The transfers and postings of Government servants have similarly been made in equally large numbers at the behest of members of the National Assembly and other members of the ruling parties. The members have violated their oath of office and the Government has not for three years taken any effective steps to ensure that the legislators do not interfere in the orderly executive functioning of Government. And whereas the Constitutional requirement that the Cabinet together with the ministers of State shall be collectively responsible to the National Assembly has been violated by the induction of a Minister against whom criminal cases are pending which the Interior Minister has refused to withdraw. In fact, at an earlier stage the Interior Minister had announced his intention to resign if the former was inducted into the Cabinet. A Cabinet in which one Minister is responsible for the prosecution of a Cabinet colleague cannot be collectively responsible in any manner whatsoever. And whereas in the matter of the sale of Burmah Castrol shares in PPL and BONE/PPL shares in Qadirpur Gas Field involving national assets valued in several billions of rupees, the President required the Prime Minister to place the matter before the Cabinet for consideration of the decisions taken in this matter by the ECC. This has still not been done, despite a lapse of over four months, in violation of the provisions of Article 46 and 48 of the Constitution. Had the President acted earlier, as was expected of him, somewhat more of the nations fast dwindling wealth might have been saved. The grounds were challenged by the dismissed Prime Minister, convinced that it was her birthright to rule over the 140 millions who make up this nation, howsoever corruptly, inefficiently and nepotistically. Oxford educated Benazir confidently chose Cambridge Chaudhry Aitzaz Ahsan and others to represent her, and Oxford educated President Leghari appointed Cambridge men Khalid Anwer and Makhdoom Ali Khan and others to respond. Her petition was heard by a Bench of seven judges of our Supreme Court, comprising Chief Justice Sajjad Ali Shah, Justices Saleem Akhtar, Fazal Elahi Khan, Zia Mehmood Mirza, Irshad Hassan Khan, Raja Afrasiab Khan, and Munawwar Ahmed Mirza. The Chief Justice and five of his brethren dismissed Benazirs petition on all counts except for the one relating to Murtazas murder, Justice Zia Mehmood Mirza dissenting. A significant development is that corruption, that has eaten into our very core, has now been adjudged as being a ground for dissolution. One other significant factor is the consistency of Justice Sajjad Ali Shah, sole dissenter in the 1993 Nawaz Sharif dissolution case when the Assembly was restored, upholding the previous judgement in the 1990 Benazir dissolution case when it was not. Thus have we been rid of the worst, the most corrupt, the most inefficient, and the most marauding government we, the people, have had the misfortune to endure and barely survive. Now we must hope again, as we always do whenever a government changes, that what that great and only statesman of ours, Mohammed Ali Jinnah, told my father Rustom, fifty years ago  that each successive government of this country was destined to be worse than its predecessor  will no more ring true. After the judgement was announced, Benazirs supporters led by Nahid Khan, danced the Jiala jig outside the Supreme Court and made a nuisance of themselves. Benazir herself, later in the evening on the BBC, came out with a couple of prize-winners: The Bhuttos cannot be defeated politically, their party the PPP cannot be defeated politically, so other means have to be found to defeat them. Did she mean that she and the party cannot be defeated politically because, in true fascistic style, they are postmasters at the art of robbing the people and the country, amassing money, and buying bogus loyalty to ensure numbers and thus frustrate any chance of a vote of no-confidence against them? The only other means available to the people are either martial law or Article 58(2)(b). The winning lawyer, Khalid Cicero Anwer, feels confident that the judgement will ensure that the future government will be a clean government and will not repeat the mistakes of the past. Meanwhile, accountability has gone to the dogs. Nothing has so far been achieved on that front. No robber of substance has been held accountable for his past misdeeds and that the big fish have all been deliberately allowed to escape through the mesh. Chief Ehtesab Commissioner Justice Ghulam Mujjadid Mirza, on television the night before the short order was announced, stated that the accountability process is being purposefully disrupted. Delays are being created by corrupt officials, and I am using the word corrupt with full responsibility, he told the people. Officials are either not interested in sending cases forward or they are incompetent. As for our banks, they are being set up by the caretakers, made ready to be easily accessible to the coming government, perfect targets for robbers and looters. How many remember that caretaker Moeen Qureshi appointed Maula Baksh Abbasi to head the NDFC against the strong protest of caretaker finance minister Babar Ali? NDFC was robbed clean, MB moved on and on and having successfully finished off all the institutions he headed under this past PPP regime, is now in Karachi Central Jail. Will Moeen Qureshi consider reimbursing the country? Does caretaker Meraj Khalid know that, quite against the wishes of the finance ministry, Ghulam Farid Abbasi has been made the chairman of our large Agricultural Development Bank of Pakistan? Governor Yaqub of the State Bank, who sat by while the banks and financial institutions were being robbed during the past three PPP years, has been re-appointed by these caretakers to head the State Bank for a further two years. The show goes on. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970206 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Benazirs refreshing stance ------------------------------------------------------------------- ONE must welcome without hesitation Ms Benazir Bhuttos pledge on Tuesday to extend her full co-operation to Mian Nawaz Sharif and work with the next government to consolidate democracy. In remarks that perhaps reflected the coming of age of Ms Bhutto as a mature political leader, the former prime minister surprised newsmen by wishing good luck to the next prime minister and alluding to his victory as one coming from God Almighty. Not even Mrs Gandhi, she said, had received such a majority after she won the war against Pakistan in 1971. Even though the PPP chairperson still expressed serious reservations about the fairness of Mondays general election and alleged manipulation of the results, the thrust of her remarks exhibited a refreshing positivism. The former prime minister drew satisfaction from the fact that the Muslim League had managed to have a two-thirds majority in the National Assembly. While she had a dig at President Leghari for failing in his purported mission to install a kings party in power, she rightly inferred that a government with a solid majority in parliament was less likely to be open to pressures from non- political forces. She, therefore, hoped that the next government would be able to complete its five-year term. What, however, Ms Bhuttos Press conference would be remembered for was her categorical declaration that she would not launch an agitation in the larger interest of democracy. In that process, the former prime minister defined what she perceived to be the Oppositions parliamentary role. Her logic was one with which no one would disagree. An agitation may bring a government down, followed by a rigged election, which would bring to power a weak government that would again be unable to complete its term and be thrown out. So this process would continue. Somebody, she said, had to bring this vicious circle to an end, and she was that person. Undeniably, both Mian Nawaz Sharifs and Ms Bhuttos hands have been tainted with intrigues of the worst kind, for neither has in the past hesitated to rely on the politics of agitation and unprincipled alliances with undemocratic forces to oust elected governments. The fall of Ms Bhuttos two governments and Mr Sharifs in 1993 stemmed from agitation, malicious intrigue and brazen street power and not from a transparent political process. The winners euphoria in each case turned out to be short-lived, for the forces that helped one overwhelm ones rival realigned with the ousted party to start the process of intrigue and extra- constitutional manoeuvring all over again. Such a scenario contributes to the peoples disillusionment with the politicians on the one hand. On the other, its deleterious consequences are to be seen in the absence of long- term economic and social planning in the country. With foreign aid having dried up in the aftermath of the end of the cold war, Third World governments can look only to foreign investment for rapid industrial expansion. Needless to say, the political goings-on in Pakistan for the last eight years have seriously obstructed, if not cut off, the flow of foreign investment in Pakistan. Every successive government in Pakistan has tended to view with hostility and suspicion projects launched and deals made by the previous government and has often cancelled even viable projects. This must stop. Foreign governments, lending agencies and multinationals deal with the country and not with the ruling party or coalition. They expect successive governments to honour deals and agreements. Any arbitrary cancellation of deals and violation of international agreements only serve to undermine foreign investors confidence in Pakistan and retard development. Ms Bhuttos offer must be seen by the victor of Mondays election in the right spirit and he must reciprocate in the same spirit. In a democracy, more so in a parliamentary one, the government and the Opposition are supposed to manage the states affairs jointly. Pakistan has not had this tradition so far, because even democratic governments  much less authoritarian ones  have tended to look at the Opposition as enemy. Let us hope Ms Bhuttos offer and the confidence which a two-thirds majority should give to Mr Sharif will enable them to make a joint endeavour to pull Pakistan out of its chaotic, undemocratic groove. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970206 ------------------------------------------------------------------- *From Jinnah to Benazir and after ------------------------------------------------------------------- Dr Iftikhar H. Malik FIFTY-SEVEN years ago on 23rd of March, 1940, a Muslim rally in the historic city of Lahore overwhelmingly endorsed a resolution stipulating the formation of a sovereign entity comprising Muslim majority provinces in British India. The motion had been moved by the All-India Muslim League, a party of Muslim modernists led by Jinnah (1876-1948), a London-trained barrister and one of the leading political voices in the subcontinent. To Jinnah and other Leaguers, the Indian National Congress, the India-wide political party founded in 1885, despite its avowed aims to serve supra- communal interests had been unable to attract Muslims. The League, itself founded in 1906, aimed at safeguarding the Muslim communitarian interests while to Mahatma Gandhi and Pandit Nehru it had come to serve merely communalist ideology. Jinnah, an avowed secularist, considered Indian political struggle for decolonisation in the 1930s and 1940s to be an international problem and refused to accept any solution to the constitutional impasse that reduced it to a mere Raj versus Congress equation. Jinnah considered Indian Muslims, compared with other communities, to be extremely underprivileged urgently needing a tangible political dispensation in the form of a sovereign state so as to engineer an uplift. His was the Muslim nationalism rather than being Islamic  a thin yet specific line differentiating a general cultural reality from a theocratic specificity. Jinnahs claim to establish territorial state and stipulating Muslim characteristics yet disallowing theocracy was hotly contested both by the ulema (religious scholars) and the regionalist ethnic elite. But his vision of a Pakistan as superordinate identity providing an honest mediation amongst various feuding religious / sectarian and regionalist / localist affiliations turned out to be a sensible and the best possible stratagem. Jinnah foresaw the existence of plural religious communities in the young republics of India and Pakistan as the most significant guarantee for it peaceful, forward-looking subcontinent. By 1947, Jinnah, an ailing man and already quite senior in age, had to suffer an immediate setback that definitely must have left him as a broken man. The transborder migrations and the accompanying ethnic cleansing in 1947 fuelled the inter-communal and inter-state tensions which, all of a sudden, overwhelmed the forces of sanity across the region. On the eve of independence, Jinnah, in his landmark speech of 11 August 1947, quite candidly observed: You are free, you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or other places of worship in this state of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion or caste or creed  that has nothing to do with the business of the State. Despite the communal riots, to the founder of the country, this creed was to anchor the official policies. He had never exploited religious sentiments to further any parochial or personal cause and used Islam in a cultural and symbolic sense to forge solidarity amongst the disparate Muslim communities and had been rebuked by Ulema who named him as the Kafir-i-Azam (the great infidel) instead of his more popular tile of the Quaid-i-Azam (the great Leader). Jinnahs vision of a democratic, tolerant, plural and egalitarian Pakistan was dashed down soon after his death when the oligarchies led by the bureaucrats and generals took over the new state and began using Islam so as to earn legitimacy for their non-representative regimes. The ulema became the unofficial ayatollahs for various regimes which inherently abhorred constitutionalism, decentralisation and accountability. In addition the very ethno-centricism of such regimes, despite their modernist postulations betrayed their national objectives. *From Ghulam Mohammad, a bureaucrat-turned executive, to his long line of successors and from generals Iskander Mirza to Ayub Khan and Zia-ul-Haq, democratic and pluralist forces were either simply suppressed or surpassed with religious symbols providing the convenient legitimising ideology. Even a populist leader like Zulfikar Ali Bhutto occasionally capitulated to religious pressures to exact political support. During the Zias regime, exploitation of religious ideology both for domestic and external purposes cost Pakistan immensely. The suppression of normal democratic processes only multiplied acute dissensions within the society and state. Other than ethnic conflict, Shia-Sunni feuds have claimed numerous innocent lives whereas politicians while mired in sleaze and unchecked corruption could not establish clean and efficient administration. The country, in a drift, has kept accumulating massive foreign debts with life for an ordinary Pakistani becoming almost unbearable. The countrys obsolete institutions allow only the landed elites to monopolise its assemblies whereas the ad hoc decisions are made by the generals and bureaucrats. Curiously, the society has been ready for radical and overdue reforms while the state keeps insisting on status quo and that is why elections have more often failed to bring in some fresh blood. Jinnahs Pakistan of parliamentary democracy exists only in ideals. Undoubtedly, for Benazir Bhutto and her predecessor (and successor, Nawaz Sharif) it was a stupendous job to retrieve democratic and tolerant values from a chaotic and fractious legacy, but that is what the leadership is all about. Ecologically, culturally, linguistically, demographically and politically, Pakistan is a well-defined polity though it does have its own share of acute ideological and ethnic problems. it is located in an arc of crises and especially in the light of unresolved problem over Kashmir with India and a constantly volatile Afghanistan, the country is awash with guns and drugs yet every sensible Pakistani desires a peaceful co-existence, a just system and a tolerant society. Pakistanis have struggled hard against odds and have been given a rough deal mostly by their own leaders who have lacked both vision and courage though the country has always welcomed political processes rather than authoritarianism and has persistently voted for moderate and mundane forces rejecting religious extremists. A vital leadership proves itself only by rising to the challenges of nation-building and time may run out for politicians as the forces of militarism and fundamentalism may sweep the country. Malady will not simply go away by just holding meaningless elections and by merely wasting public funds and resources on ostentatious regalia. Pakistan does need a transparent and responsible government that may come about only through internal stability, consolidation of democracy and an accountable system. Religious freedom, democracy and tolerance as promised and visualised by the founders of the country need to be implemented and the country is definitely ready for that. While the policymakers, police and administrative machinery may be corrupt and inept, efforts for a cleaner and decentralised civil administration must be given priority. Similarly the religious and ethnic leaders have to be reined in through negotiations and by non-partisan and bold cooptive initiatives. The mafia gangs, loan/tax defaulters and similar other criminals  disallowing any personal/political favour  must not be left at large. Similarly, there is greater need to initiate overdue dialogue with India in the spirit of regional co-operation to redirect the scarce funds towards development schemes addressed at a vast youthful expectant society. These are the tasks which would not only put Pakistan on its right Jinnahist tracks but would also elevate present leaders as the pioneers for a more democratic, just and forward-looking Pakistan. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970201 ------------------------------------------------------------------- The moment of truth ------------------------------------------------------------------- Mazdak BY the time this column appears, the Supreme Court will have delivered its verdict, and the nation will have found out whether or not it is going to be called yet again to elect a new government. Apart from legal uncertainties, one reason for the lukewarm reaction of voters to the whole exercise is the fact that this is the fourth time their decision has been ultimately overruled by that shadowy group that is collectively called the Establishment. To be sure, our short-sighted, venal and inefficient leaders give this group every excuse for sacking them. The rest of us are disgusted and depressed spectators of this tired game of musical chairs. So the average Pakistani voter can be forgiven his lack of enthusiasm. But over and above this disenchantment with our political class is anger over the arrogance of a handful of men who think they know what is good for us, and pre-empt our right to throw an unacceptable government out. In brief, what we are told time and again is that while we have the right to vote a party into power, we do not have the right to throw it out when its term is over. This power, it seems, has been reserved only for the President and his men. It is important to realise that this right is the other side of the democratic coin: unless elected leaders realise that the same voters who brought them into the corridors of power can show them the door, they will forget about them once installed. After their swearing in, they will pay lip-service to the electorate, while focusing on pleasing the (unelected) Establishment that is perceived to hold the key to power. It is a historical fact that while several governments have been voted into power in Pakistan, not a single one has been voted out. And at each dissolution of assemblies, it has been a case of the Establishment knowing what is best for us, never mind that each time, we have been landed in a bigger mess. More than once, these illegal or quasi-constitutional interventions have been motivated by ambition masquerading under the garb of concern over the state of the nation. The answer to poorly managed democracy is more  and not less  democracy. And yet there are intelligent and highly educated people in this country who doubt the average voters ability to cast his vote sensibly. However, this same elite seldom bothers to register their names on the electoral list, and take the trouble to actually queue up and vote even less frequently. This disdain of the common mans common sense reflects a paternalistic attitude not far removed from the whole ethos behind Kiplings White Mans Burden. Uneducated natives, it seems, cannot discern between good and bad candidates, and therefore, the Establishment is forced to intervene from time to time to rescue them from the results of their own folly. Forget that more often than not, this rescue operation causes far more problems than it resolves. One of the major problems with both the previous elected governments was that once in power, both Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif seemed to act as though they were not answerable to parliament and the electorate but to the President and the COAS of the day. If it has achieved anything at all, the infamous Article 58(2)(b) of the Constitution has eroded the sovereignty of the people by conferring the power to arbitrarily dissolve Parliament on a single individual. Proponents of this constitutional aberration  a large and highly articulate tribe  argue that this article has prevented the imposition of martial law. They also hold that by creating a balance of power between the prime minister and the president, 58 (2)(b) has curtailed executive excesses. But has it? As we have been witnessing these past eight years, successive governments have acted irresponsibly and capriciously without a thought to presidential prerogative until the very last minute. So rather than acting as a brake to bad governance, this article has served as a sledgehammer. What then is the answer? We are still smarting from the wounds inflicted by Asif Zardari and his ilk on the exchequer as well as our pride, so can we afford unfettered executive authority? Im afraid theres no easy answer, no quick fix to ensure responsible government. Our politicians have to mature, our electorate has to become more demanding and our democratic institutions have to put down roots before we get clean, decent government. Easier said than done, I know, specially as the enormity of the problems facing us is such that we do not have the luxury of unlimited time at our disposal. However, if we reject the democratic system because of the insatiable greed of a few individuals, we will be doing ourselves and future generations a huge disservice. Experience around the world has shown that with all its imperfections, this is the only system that holds out the promise of development coupled with social justice. Autocratic rule of every type has been consigned to the dustbin of history. Our case is not unique: other democracies have had their teething problems, their share of crooks and charlatans and the occasional temptation to take the dictatorial path. But by and by, they have progressed to a point where any other system is simply unthinkable. When you read this, elections will be only two days away. People ask me who Ill vote for. I honestly dont know. I do know that I cant possibly vote for any ethnic or sectarian party. I am a liberal person, with all that the term implies, and I honestly dont know whether any party today qualifies for my vote. Nevertheless, come election day, and I will be standing in line, probably still wondering who to vote for.

===================================================================

SPORTS

970201 ------------------------------------------------------------------- A fitting case for world Test championship ------------------------------------------------------------------- Lateef Jafri ON return from Australia after outplaying the home side and outwitting the Caribbean cavaliers and with the World Series cup in his possession captain Wasim Akram expressed the wish that there should be a Test World Cup among the full members of the International Cricket Council. Among the strong cricketing nations only South Africa was unrepresented at the Australian World Series venture, fulfilling their own commitment initially in India and latterly at home grounds. Wasim, after piloting the country to deserving and desired victories against Australia and West Indies, was happy that the challenge of two formidable forces in global cricket was courageously met and brushed aside on an alien soil and thought that time had arrived for the competition to be raised to a higher plane  a five-day tussle in Test matches to decide ``the real and genuine champion of the world. Certainly he had no format ready but he backed the idea of a bigger extravaganza in the style and manner of the 21-year limited-overs World Cup, which was launched in the summer of 1975 at Lords with a match between India and England. This was to be the inaugural contest for the one-day honours of the world, eventually clinched by the powerful West Indians. The last championship or the title (if the latter connotation is to be taken as correct) was claimed by Sri Lanka. Every country and critic had to accept the leap forward they had made and the high position they had attained in the cricketing world by their mettlesome players, fighters to the core on the South Asian fields. But ironically enough the World Cup winners were brought down from their high pedestal just a fortnight later in Singapore by Pakistan in the Singer Cup. However, the Lahore final decided the champions of nascent cricket, as acknowledged by the ICC. Will the representatives of the ICC move forward to consider and discuss in detail the Test World Cup plan, if at all it can be taken out of the Lords cold storage. Wasim Akram said it would be a good change (from one-dayers) and people would know which is the best team in the world in this strenuous and rigorous five-day contest. Mark Taylor, after his spinners Michael Bevan and Shane Warne had baffled the West Indian at Adelaide and the Australians had won the rubber and kept the Frank Worrell Trophy, had laid claim to be the new kings of world Test cricket. He dismissed the view that the West Indies were giants of Test cricket. Certainly if two captains, one having grabbed the one-day World Series Cup and the other having lifted the coveted Worrell Trophy, emphasise the need and necessity of a tussle among the Test playing countries the proposal cannot be ignored. World famous medium-pacer and all-rounder Sir Richard Hadlee of New Zealand had recently come out with the suggestion of Super Test or world championship of Tests. He thought that day by day the limited-overs competition was getting so much encouragement that interest in Test matches is waning. Nevertheless, the litmus test to determine the strength and weakness of national line-ups was the five-day enterprise. A global contest involving the nine Test-playing countries would not only attract the marketing multinationals and sponsoring mega-industries but would give considerable boost to Test cricket and prove once again that it were the five-day battles which settle the cricket championship and not the one-day spectacles, now numbering over hundred in one calendar year. The proposal had also been voiced in the recent past by Clive Lloyd, Hansie Cronje, Ian Chappell and Sunil Gavaskar among other renowned figures of the game. However, at the country level it was Dr Ali Bacher of the United Cricket Board of South Africa who strongly supported the proposal of Tests World Cup. Hadlee, in his suggestion, had detailed a points system for the matches and the players. The venues had to be in large numbers in diverse countries according to the New Zealand legend. However just to remind the cricket fans it may be mentioned that former Chief Executive of Pakistans Board, Arif Ali Abbasi, had prepared a thorough and detailed proposal on the subject and despatched it to the International Cricket Council headquartered at Lords before its annual representative meeting. Abbasi was shunted out of office before he could brief the ICC delegates on Pakistans proposal and lobby the idea for endorsement. The former cricket supremo wanted Pakistan to be the central place for staging the matches. He was confident of getting the sponsorship on a major scale for such a big venture. Thirty-nine matches were played during the fifth World Cup in Australia and New Zealand in 1992. The South Asian-organised sixth edition of the venture had 37 ties to be arranged. If group-wise Test matches are to be gone through in a round-robin style perhaps not more than 20 matches will be competed. The whole idea could have been given a practical shape after endorsement from the ICC delegates, which was not difficult considering that South Africa was prepared to stand by Pakistan and Sri Lanka and India would have given support to the new cricket plan as Jagmohan Dalmia was being backed for the top ICC post by Pakistan. The lobbying at Lords would have paid the dividends and more delegates would have lined up with Pakistan. Regrettably, the new PCB Chief Executive, Majid Khan, who attended last Junes annual meeting of ICC, was lukewarm to the idea of world championship of Tests and did not do the effort needed at Lords. The proposal was talked out. On return the famed cricketer pointed to logistics and sponsorship problems and told the sports scribes that the idea was impracticable as far as Pakistan was concerned. Countries like Australia, South Africa and India may be successful in such a big project. As the Chief Executive pointed out last June, the staging of such a big gala as the Test World Cup was well nigh impossible in this country with the multi-sided problems that it has, it is better to cite an example from history. It was in the summer of 1912 that triangular Test matches were played in England among Australia, South Africa and England. At that time there were only three contestants as they were the countries exchanging visits for Test duels. All the encounters were arranged at Englands venues and ultimately after the league tussles Australia came second to England with South Africa, then a weak conglomerate, finishing last. England with such legends as Hobbs, Spooner, Fry, Woolley and Warner were solid in batting. The bowling had the pace of S. F. Barnes and F. R. Foster and the superb tricks of Rhodes, Woolley and Hearne. It was an unbeatable side. Australia were not at full strength. England, with one of the strongest squads ever, duly won the triangular series. The experiment was a grand success. In modern times when facilities have so much expanded and the chances of sponsorship and marketing have become so much bright there is little doubt that a world championship of Tests, if launched, will attract huge crowds and achieve the desired results financially. Now that the ICC meeting is not very far away one expects the PCB to put forward the proposal before the delegates and get their endorsement. Cricket will get considerable boost in the country. More modern facilities in cricket centres may be provided. Besides it will be a unique venture which will make the coffers of the PCB helftier and heavier. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970203 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Rashid Latif not available for Dhaka trip ------------------------------------------------------------------- Sports Reporter KARACHI, Feb 2: Rashid Latif on Sunday withdrew himself from the SAARC cricket contest to be played in Dhaka, Bangladesh, for which he was appointed vice-captain. The discarded Test wicketkeeper cited serious domestic commitments for pulling out. I have to take care of certain serious assignments at home. It would be unwise to leave them at this stage, said Rashid. The Dhaka tournament will be played between Feb 17 and 28. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970203 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Five-nation event to be held in Karachi ------------------------------------------------------------------- Walter Fernandez KARACHI, Feb 2: The Secretary of the Pakistan Hockey Federation (PHF), Col. Mudassar Asghar, told `Dawn here on Saturday that the Five-Nation Hockey Tournament scheduled to be held in the city from March 16 to 23 will definitely go on. All the rumours floated about the shifting of the tournament from the city to Lahore are simply unfounded, added Col. Mudassar Asghar. The Five-Nation tournament, a part of the countrys Golden Jubilee celebrations, besides host Pakistan will feature Germany, the Netherlands, Australia and England. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970204 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Akram decides to skip international events ------------------------------------------------------------------- By Samiul Hasan KARACHI, Feb 3: The tough off-season commitments of the Pakistan cricket team made skipper Wasim Akram its first scalp when the allrounder pulled out from at least three international tournaments. The PIA and Lancashire allrounder has made himself available for Pakistan only till April and will thus appear in the Sharjah Cup and two Tests against Sri Lanka. With the English County Championships starting in the third week of April, Wasim Akram will proceed to the North of England from Sri Lanka and will miss Mays Singer Cup in Singapore, Sahara Cup in Canada and Asia Cup in Sri Lanka (both in August). According to well informed sources, Pakistans tour to India for three one- day internationals in May have fallen in jeopardy. The PCB had inquired me of my commitments and though I have not informed them officially, I have made up my mind that I will only play for Pakistan till April before rejoining the team in September, Wasim Akram told this correspondent on Monday. Pakistan will be hosting three major events between September and December. Pakistan will be organising a quadrangular tournament at Lahore to be competed by Sri Lanka, South Africa and the West Indies. Pakistan also hold a separate three-Test series each with South Africa and the West Indies. While Wasim Akram has decided about his priorities, Waqar Younis and Mushtaq Ahmad are also likely to follow in the footsteps of their skipper. Waqar has signed a lucrative two-year contract with Glamorgan while Mushtaq has a three-year commitment with Somerset. Although out of selectors favours, Mohammad Akram also has a contract with Northamptonshire. Besides these four, a few more cricketers viz Ijaz Ahmad Senior, Mohammad Zahid, Shahid Nazir, Mohammad Wasim and Saqlain Mushtaq have signed with some English clubs. Saeed Anwar is also negotiating with two countiesHampshire and Essexand appears certain to join either of the two. Wasim Akram said he has a county bound for another year. I had finalised my commitment well in advance. In this background, the PCB inquired me of my plans which I will be conveying to the board. Akram said if he tried to skip matches with Lancashire, his contract for the next year may suffer. 1998 is my benefit year and I dont want to ruin it. Of course, the PCB understand this. They (Lancashire) wants me for full season and thats precisely why they are paying me so heavily. According to an estimate, Akram is getting 100,000 pounds per season while Waqar Younis has signed a two-year contract at 220,000 pounds with Glamorgan, the former county of Viv Richards and Javed Miandad. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970205 ------------------------------------------------------------------- Will results affect PCB set-up? ------------------------------------------------------------------- Sports Reporter KARACHI, Feb 4: After the landslide victory of PML (N) in the general elections, a major reshuffle is most likely to take place in the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) hierarchy. The present President of the PCB, Syed Zulfiqar Ali Shah Bokhari, who won a National Assembly seat for PPP from Jhang in 1993, was not one of the contestants this time as PML (N) virtually made a clean sweep of the Jhang constituency with only one seat going to an independent candidate. The Treasurer of the PCB, Salman Taseer, who won the National Assembly PPP seat in 1993 from Lahore II, crashed to defeat by 35,178 votes in NA-93 as he could get only 27,887 votes as compared to PML (N) Mian Abdul Waheed who secured 63,065 votes. The two PCB officials were political appointees during Benazir Bhuttos government whose Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) failed to find a firm footing in the current elections. It will not be out of context to mention here that the President of Pakistan is the Patron of the PCB and the two top posts are honorary jobs while the Chief Executive is a paid one. The Chief Executive of the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB), Majid Khan, who succeeded Arif Abbasi about eight months ago, may also be under pressure. His family sources in Lahore confirmed that he is already in Islamabad. In the background as to what happened after three general elections of 1988, 1990 and 1993 and the changes thereafter in the cricket board offices, the analysts believe that the new government will also follow in the traditions of the previous rulers. After PPPs 1988 victory, Lt Gen (Retd) Zahid Ali Akbar was made BCCP President while Arif Abbasi was appointed Secretary. Nevertheless, when PML (N) came into power in 1990, Arif Abbasi made way for Shahid Rafi in 1991. But when PPP came into powers again after October 1993 elections, the officials of the then BCCPthe then Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Dr Nasim Hasan Shah, and Shahid Rafi, Chairman, Pakistan Television (President and Secretary respectively), had to leave the posts and that too at a time when the then BCCP General Body dinner was taking place at a five-star hotel in Lahore on Jan 12. Chief Justice (Retd) Nasim Hasan Shahs board was superseded by a three- member ad hoc committee (Javed Burki, Arif Abbasi and Dr Zafar Altaf). The officials of the renamed PCB were appointed in March 1995 with Arif Abbasi as its first paid Chief Executive. Soon after the World Cup, Arif Abbasis contentious appointment in the eyes of his rivals came to an end when he was replaced by former Pakistan captain and renowned cricketer Majid Khan who was then the Director of Sports in Pakistan Television. Cricket observes do not rule out the possibility of a change in the current set-up of the PCB. Hasib Ahsan, former chairman of selectors, said it was a great change in political front that Mian Nawaz Sharif came into power with such an overwhelming majority. Not only the bigger province has supported him, smaller ones have also thrown their weight behind him. It now depends on him to carry the objectives of all, Ahsan said. Ahsan endorsed Nawaz Sharifs claims of accountability but added accountability should also be done in cricket especially in connection with the World Cup where several lucrative contracts were awarded to favourite people. Those responsible for throwing away the money in cricket should also be penalised and Nawaz Sharif is the right man to do the job. Ahsan said changes in the PCB may be imminent. I personally feel that reshuffling will start in the next few months. Its time that Chief Justice (Retd) Nasim Hasan Shahs dented reputation be restored by appointing him to serve as PCB chief for one term. Similarly, Shahid Rafi should also be given a chance to continue his good job which was broken in 1994. After all, time has proved that most of his decisions, including the appointment of Wasim Akram, who now lead the team after four captains were tried, Ahsan concluded. Razaullah Khan, a former BCCP Councillor and a balanced critic, emphasised that changes should be made. The cricket picture tells a very sorry story. No doubt the team has been winning, we have been losing at many fronts, observed Razaullah. Razaullah said Majid Khan has failed to come up to expectations as he badly failed as an administrator. He added domestic cricket was in shambles, cricket board was confined to just a single zone and World Cup accounts were yet to be settled. Mian Nawaz Sharif is a keen cricketer and he has come through a democratic process, he should enforce democracy in the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) where there should be representation of all the provinces, Razaullah said. DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS*DWS 970201 ------------------------------------------------------------------- PSFs obligation and future of squash ------------------------------------------------------------------- A. Majid Khan While the Pakistan Squash Federation carries no responsibility for our players participation, so far as the super series and other tournaments controlled by the Professional Squash Association were concerned, but it certainly owes a national obligation to prepare teams for competing in the team and individual events under the auspices of the World Squash Federation, the controlling body of the game in the world of which Pakistan is one of the founder members. The players are free to compete in the PSA tournaments, a good number of them carry rich prize money of over US dollars 50,000/- such as the British Open, World Open, Pakistan Open, Hong Kong Open, Mahindra Open, Alahram International and JSM Super Squash. Besides the super series, other events, lesser in monetary terms, come under the bracket of major tournaments. For a few years a new trend has taken hold of international squash whereby as low as 10,000 dollars or even less prize money are offered for the players seeking to improve their rankings. In these events world ranking stars and other renowned players usually do not compete. But the host country feels happy if its world ranking players do compete in the lesser tournaments for it considerably helps in improving the competitive standard of others and also provides an opportunity to play against the top players of the world. Last year four PSA approved international tournaments were held in Pakistan, two in Lahore, and one each in Peshawar and Wah. Jansher Khan, Zubair Jahan, Zarak Jahan, Mir Zaman Gul competed in the tournament. Besides them a number of up-and-coming players, including those who competed in the Juniors World championship as also, a good number of foreign players. By holding such tournaments the squash activities in Pakistan had gained further momentum and this year it would be helped our new generation of players to improve their skill. The Pakistan Squash Federation, it is gathered, had almost finalised the 1997 domestic calendar and is expected to be announced next month, after getting it confirmed from the organisers of the events. The PSFs first international commitment is the participation of Pakistan in the eighth Asian Juniors Championship, scheduled in the Indian City of Madras from Feb 14-22. During the nine-day tournament both boys and girls individual and team championship would be held. The PSF is sending two girls as part of the Pakistan contingent. Pakistan has also entered for the first time in the World Doubles Championship to be staged in Hong Kong from May 4-11 this year. Preparations for the World Doubles squash immediately requires holding of competitions at Lahore, Peshawar, Karachi and Rawalpindi or Islamabad on courts bearing standard dimensions to develop understanding among the players. The PSF too can follow this practice for the Hong Kong Doubles as the time is running out. The event would be staged five weeks after the conclusion of the first super series British Open in Cardiff, Wales on April 6. All the Pakistans world ranking stars would be on the international circuit. Holding the doubles tournaments on all Pakistan basis considered essential and the PSF should take necessary steps ensuring at least four events before a camp is organised for selection of the national team. The PSF has to work out its doubles programme in a way that it does not clash with leading players participation in the PSA tournaments. It would be more appropriate that technical committee be appointed for running the doubles tournament and the rules of the doubles game be made known to the players before starting a tournament. Another important event in which Pakistan has also entered is the World Games which includes Squash as well. The World Games include those sports, which are not included in the Olympics games. The World Squash Federation is making persistent effort for the games inclusion in the Olympics and inclusion of squash in the World Games is a step forward in achieving the desired goal. The inclusion of squash in the 1998 Asian Games has been a major achievement and would give tremendous boost to the Game in Asia. The World Games, according to the announced programme of the WSF, is scheduled from Aug 13-17 at Lathi, Finland. Both men and women teams events would be contested on the Olympic pattern. Pakistans World Champion Jansher Khans participation, along with other leading players of the world such as Australias Rodney Eyles, Peter Nicol (Scotland), Englands Chris Walker and Simon Parke, Jonathan Power (Canada), Egyptian Ahmed Barada, Australias Brett Martin, Englands Del Harris and Pakistans Zubair Khan, being among the world top ten players, would brighten the squash chances for inclusion of squash in the future world Olymics. The last event in which Pakistan is fully committed to take part is the World Team Championship, to be followed soon after the World Open is starting from Nov 4-9 at the Malaysian capital Kuala Lumpur. The World Open is PSA event and the PSF has nothing to do with this super series event for it is up to the players to compete in this rich prize money tournament. The PSFs concern is with the team championship as it is under the domain of the World Squash Federation to which it is affiliated. The professional Squash Association is an organisation of players, belonging to different countries including Pakistan. The WSF 1997 calendar is very demanding on the part of the Pakistan Squash Federation both in term of its financial needs as well as team preparations for the coming tournaments. Back to the top.

Dawn page